Yu-Gi-Oh!, also referred to as Yugioh, is a Japanese trading card game (TCG) based on the manga game called dueling monsters.
It was extremely popular in the US after its release in Japan in 1999 and the US in 2002, even earning the Guiness World Record for Top Trading Card Game in 2009, with over 22 billion cards sold.
If you were born in the 90s, you probably dueled your friends at some in Yugioh and even watched the popular animated series at the time.
Now, while Yugioh cards helped millions of kids around the world get into the magic of collectable card games, the game is far from obsolete.
In fact, many cards have retained their value or seen a pretty substantial increase in value over the years, which is why there is a huge market of people either collecting them or trying to sell them.
So, if you find a box of old Yugioh cards when you’re spring cleaning, there’s a slim chance you’re sitting on hundreds or thousands of dollars in value.
If you’re looking to make some quick cash and want to find the best place to sell Yugioh cards, this is absolutely the post for you.
Keep reading to find out what may be affecting the price of your cards, how to determine their value, and where you can go to sell your cards.
What Influences Yugioh Card Prices?
Before we get into how to sell Yugioh cards for money, we need to cover what actually makes a card valuable.
There are a few different factors which will determine how you can price your cards on the market, including condition, if it’s a set, rarity, and overall demand.
In terms of condition, cards are usually rated from ‘heavy play’ to ‘mint’. Cards that got a lot of use when you were younger may have taken a bit of a beating, which will drive down the price.
However, if you have cards in protective sleeves or, even better, unopened packs, you might have some near-mint condition cards that are more valuable than their damaged counterparts.
Yugioh has released tons of sets and booster packs over the years, with limited edition cards scattered throughout.
If you have a complete set from a given year, you might be able to sell it and make a greater profit than you would if you sold the cards individually. Once again, it’s important to check the value of your items beforehand to determine this.
Yugioh cards are often purchased in TCG sets, which include an assortment of 9 cards ranging from common to rare. There are several different rankings in card rarity, each with its own qualities used to distinguish them:
- Common. The first tier in rarity, they won’t have any foil or embellishment on them and are pretty easy to find– meaning they won’t make you all that much on their own.
- Rare. Have textured silver foil as the card name, but no holographic finish on the imaging.
- Super Rare. Have no textured foil but do have a holographic finish on the art.
- Ultra Rare. Have gold foil on the card name and are holographic.
- Ultimate Rare. These cards have gold foil, in addition to textured foil accents on the art, around the border, and across other areas of the card itself.
- Secret Rare. These will have rainbow foil on the card name and a sparkling holographic finish.
- Ghost Rare. Also have rainbow foil as the card name, but the card art will be a 3D hologram.
- Starfoil Rare. Have ‘starburst-patterned’ foil scattered across the front of the card.
- Mosaic Rare. Have multiple sections of foil all over the face of the card.
- Duelist League. The are promotional and only available by participating in a Duelist League. They are distinguished by the card name colours, which are not available through regular sales.
Konami, the company that created Yugioh, reprinted many cards over the years, which has resulted in cards losing their value as they become common cards.
So, while some cards were originally made as limited editions with special foil, they were reprinted later as common cards which have little value.
First Edition and Limited Edition cards are recognizable by the gold security foil in the bottom right of the card, while Unlimited Edition cards– which are reprinted– have silver foil.
First and Limited Edition cards will turn way more of a profit than the Unlimited cards, so pay close attention to the foiling to determine their worth.
This sounds like a lot of info, but it pays to know the rarity of your cards so you can determine their potential more quickly.
Another factor that influences how valuable your Yugioh cards are is how useful they are for actual play.
How valuable a card is in a metagame tournament can have a major effect on price.
Meta refers to the decks and strategies that are currently in use and dominating tournaments.
When a card is too powerful in tournaments it will sometimes get banned, so it’s important to check the Yugioh ban list to stay on top of your cards’ relevance to meta tournaments.
The Takeaway: there’s a lot of information to digest before you try to sell your Yugioh cards for money.
Learn the basics of how to identify and value and card, and also try websites like Yugioh Prices to find the price of specific cards you’re considering selling.
I’d start by separating cards based on condition (very damaged cards won’t sell chances are) and then by rarity. Next, check the price of each card individually before putting them up for sale.
The Best Places to Sell Yugioh Cards – Online Options
If you’re wondering where you can sell Yugioh cards for cash, you’re in luck!
Some of the best places for selling Yugioh cards are reputable online marketplaces that make it easy to upload your collection and find a buyer to sell to.
You can sell just about anything on eBay.
Plus, there’s a massive market for trading cards and collectibles, so it’s no surprise that Yugioh cards are easy to find on the platform.
Now, eBay does charge a sellers fee that falls between 5-10% on every item, which is still lower than many sites devoted to selling TCGs.
However, the sheer size of eBay makes it one of the best places to sell Yugioh cards, especially if you’re listing an entire collection and bulk selling.
You’re going to want to price your cards carefully and competitively, so it’s helpful to use a platform like Yugioh Prices.
Yugioh Prices is useful for searching card prices quickly. Plus, you can also add cards to a watch list and get notified when the price increases or drops.
Yugioh Prices also lets you create an eBay listing through their site, which is helpful as it autofills the information regarding the name, set, and print tag, and offers a suggested sale price based on current trends and value.
Extra Reading – The Best Places To Sell Pokemon Cards.
2. Heart Of The Cards
Another option for selling Yugioh cards online is Heart of the Cards; an appropriate name for a store that deals with Yugioh!
Heart of the Cards will accept your near mint or slightly played cards and give you 40% in cash for their market value.
If you’re looking to expand your collection you can also get 50% back in store credit and use it towards some new purchases.
They’re a bit more picky about the condition of foiled cards, since damage is usually quite visible.
They are even more strict about Yugioh cards since there are so many foil cards available, but it’s a good resource to use if you want someone else to do the selling for you.
Overall, you won’t get the highest value for your sale using something like this, since they’re also trying to turn a profit, so don’t be surprised if you can’t get full market value for your collection.
3. Card Market
Card Market is another major platform for buying and selling cards, and you just need to create an account to get started.
With Card Market, you can search your card and select the condition before listing your own price— but once again it’s good to do some research and price your card accordingly.
Payment is done through bank wire transfer or PayPal, and Card Market takes a 5% commission on every sale.
There is also a 3% currency conversion fee since it’s an international platform.
If you want a fast way to sell your Yugioh cards without getting gouged on pricing, Card Market is worth considering.
4. Troll and Toad
Another one of the best places to sell Yugioh cards, or almost any TCG card game, is to go through Troll and Toad.
Troll and Toad will buy directly from you and resell your items themselves.
All you need to do is browse their buy list and find your cards, you will then see the selling price and the amount they are willing to purchase from you.
Payment can be issued by check, PayPal or as a website credit (which will earn you a 50% bonus). Once they receive your cards and verify the order, the amount will be processed in about 5 business days.
Just note: Troll and Toad requires a minimum $30 value for the cards you’re selling, so this website isn’t ideal if you have a small collection of cards that aren’t worth very much.
5. TCG Player
One additional option to sell online is TCG Player, one of the longstanding and respected players in the trading card market.
TCG Player has an immense amount of inventory and game variety, including Pokemon, Magic The Gathering, Yugioh, and dozens of other card games.
Yugioh is still incredibly popular on the site, and the selling process is pretty straightforward.
TCG Player charges a 10.25% selling fee (capped at $50 for each card) for regular marketplace sellers, which will be charged once a sale is made.
Payment is made through direct deposit to your bank account, after the sale has been confirmed and fees have been deducted.
Ultimately, TCG Player has some of the best live pricing data out there.
Plus, you can instantly create listings for thousands of cards at a time by using their pre-existing database to upload information.
One long-standing player in the TCG and tradables market is Sell2BBNovelties.
And, if you want to sell Yugioh cards online, it’s a fairly effective option. That’s because you have two different methods to sell:
- Sell individual Yugioh cards to Sell2BBNovelties
- Sell cards in bulk
Sell2BBNovelties also outlines various prices for cards depending on their rarity. Current prices include:
- Holographics: $0.10 per card (this includes super, ultra, and secret rare cards)
- Rares: $0.03 each
- Commons: $0.01 each
However, Sell2BBNovelties states that it purchases many cards for higher values if you list them individually, so keep this in mind for your super rare cards to get the most money possible.
Sell2BBNovelties also buys booster packs, boxes, and card tins.
Just note: to sell your Yugioh cards, your cards must be in mint or like new condition.
Sell2BBNovelties pays with PayPal cash or store credit. The company pays for shipping if you sell over $30 of cards.
7. Reddit r/YGOMarketplace
While Reddit is probably best known for various memes and niche communities, it’s also one of the best places to sell Yugioh cards.
The r/YGOMarketplace subreddit is home to over 12,000 duelists who want to buy, sell, and trade Yugioh cards amongst themselves.
Reddit actually has lots of communities like this; you can find subreddits for trading gift cards, Steam games, and even Christmas gifts.
What makes YGOMarketplace useful is the list of rules and buyer/seller feedback systems.
Basically, every member has a list of how many transactions they’ve completed, and members can leave positive or negative feedback as well.
Ultimately, this means you can spot reputable buyers with proven track records. There are also several mods and a useful FAQ section to help new members get started.
You can also meet buyers in person depending on where you both live, making r/YGOMarketplace one of the most versatile ways to sell Yugioh cards for cash.
8. Dave & Adam’s
Dave & Adam’s is another major name in the collectibles and trading card space.
According to its website, Dave & Adam’s is always buying cards. So, if you want to sell Yugioh cards, your first step is to check its current buy list for a list of cards you can sell.
Dave & Adam’s is currently buying loads of Yugioh booster packs, boxes, and individual cards.
This website also has some lucrative offers; plenty of booster packs and boxes are available for resale for around $100 to $3,000 or more.
Obviously, these top prices are for rare booster packs and tins, but hey, it’s nice to see a company that’s willing to pay you thousands of dollars for your cards.
Dave & Adam’s pays through PayPal or check.
One slight downside is that you need to sell over $199 to get free shipping. But, on the bright side, Dave & Adam’s usually gives gifts like free cards or some store credit for large sales, so you get something back.
9. Game Goblins
If you’re still wondering how to sell Yugioh cards, Game Goblins is one more online option to try.
Like Dave & Adam’s, the best way to see if you can sell is to consult the current buy list.
I like Game Goblins’ buy list since it’s actually on a Google Sheet, so you can quickly search for Yugioh cards you want to sell by card number and set.
Most cards have offers for between a $5 to $25, but Game Goblins still buys plenty of cards for $50 to $100+ depending on the rarity and set.
According to Game Goblins, the company “use TCGPlayer’s low price as a base and offer up to 65% of a card’s current value in cash.”
You can also sell Yugioh cards for store credit and get a 25% bonus for trading-in.
If you’re a serious table-top games or trading card fan, going for store credit could actually be one of the best ways to get maximum value for your Yugioh cards.
In any case, Game Goblins also states that buyers grade your cards and print a sheet detailing each individual card offer and total value, so you can review all the details before accepting a sale.
If you’re still wondering: where can I sell Yugioh cards, your next best bet might be Mercari.
Mercari is a popular selling app where you can list almost anything for free as a seller and make extra cash when you find an online buyer.
A perk of selling on Mercari vs marketplaces like eBay is that Mercari provides prepaid shipping labels (unless you offer free shipping) and lets you list very easily right from your smartphone.
However, Mercari does charge 10% in commission for sellers, so keep this in mind.
But, if you want to sell your Yugioh cards online quickly and don’t mind the commission, apps like Mercari are worth trying.
Yugioh cards are actually surprisingly popular on Mercari, and people are selling everything from single, ultra-rare cards to entire collections and box sets.
One thing that I like about Mercari is that people also sell lower value, basic Yugioh cards, so you don’t just have to have super rare cards to sell on this platform.
Extra Reading – The Best Things To Sell On Mercari.
Where To Sell YuGiOh Cards Near Me?
If you don’t want to sell online, there are a few options in terms of brick and mortar locations that you can find with a simple Google search:
The Facebook Marketplace has the ease and variety of eBay, but the simplicity of local sales by pickup or drop-off. If you want to sell Yugioh cards for cash near you, it’s hard to find a better solution.
The importance here is to offer quality photos and detailed descriptions of your items, so people will trust the sale.
If you’re selling in bulk, setting a reasonable price for all your cards could get you a sale pretty quickly, as people will be willing to bank on the chance of there being a high value card included.
If you want to do the research on your cards and find the rare or competitive card within your collection, that may also help you make the sale, especially if people are on the hunt for a specific card.
Extra Reading – What Sells Best On Facebook Marketplace?
12. Pawn Shops
These can be a little tricky, as not all pawn shops will have knowledge of TCGs and their worth. It helps to call ahead and check if they’re interested in these items, as not all pawn shops will be.
You’re also guaranteed to get way below market value in this case, but if you’re selling in bulk and don’t care too much about price, it could be worth your time.
Do a quick Google search for “where to sell Yugioh cards near me” and see if any pawn shops pop up in your local search results. If some do, call them to confirm.
Extra Reading – What Can I Pawn For $500?
13. Comic Book Stores
These will be a bit better than pawn shops, as they’re pretty much guaranteed to be familiar with Yugioh cards and their approximate worth.
It’s basically the in-store equivalent to Heart of the Cards, where you get a fraction of the value of your card– but it’s faster and easier than shipping them out.
Again, I’d call ahead to confirm you can sell your Yugioh cards nearby to a comic book store in your area.
14. Find A Friend
If you’re still looking to sell Yugioh cards near you, your last but simplest option is just to sell to a friend.
If you play in drafts or duels at a local comic book store or card shop, you might already have friends who play Yugioh like you.
So, if you’re getting rid of some cards or are dropping the game altogether, you might as well ask the people you know first if they want to buy your cards.
What Option Is Best?
If you’re looking to make the most off your cards, direct seller sites are guaranteed to get that for you.
eBay or TCG Player are the most popular way to sell cards, so if you’re willing to do the work to set prices and list each item, you’re guaranteed to get the highest value for your cards.
It is, however, a very slow process.
You not only have to take the time to research and list your items, but it can be a while before you make a sale.
There’s an additional waiting period for payment on platforms like TCG Player, as they have to verify the sale and process your payment before you actually see the funds.
If you’re looking for a quick sale and you’re not too worried about value, selling Yugioh cards nearby for cash is your best bet.
If you’re selling in bulk you can easily get a set price for your collection and be done with it pretty fast.
Definitely do a quick check on the rarity of your cards though, cause in person retailers might try and scam you out of a high value card if they know you’re unaware of its worth.
Tips For How To Sell Yugioh Cards
So, you now know where to sell Yugioh cards and can choose between online or in-person options depending on your preferences and where you live.
But, if you’re wondering how to sell Yugioh cards in the easiest, safest way possible, here are some selling tips to keep in mind and step-by-step guide on how selling works:
- Organize Your Cards (Preliminary Sweep). To make life easier as a seller, scan through all of your cards and remove cards that are seriously damaged. Cards with creases, white edges, scratches, and other obvious signs of damage are pretty much impossible to sell.
- Organize Cards By Rarity & Set. Once you weed out cards with damage, group your Yugioh cards into piles based on rarity and set. For example, this could mean grouping all of your holographic cards into a pile from the 2010 Duelist Pack Collection Tin, which is a particular set. If you don’t have that many cards, just group cards by rarity and don’t worry about the set.
- Research Rare Card Prices. Once you have your rare, ultra rare, holographic, and other more valuable cards, research the current market price for each card. Again, websites like Yugioh Prices let you search for specific card pricing.
- Make A Card Price List. Record all of the pricing data for the cards you want to sell in an Excel spreadsheet. As you become more familiar with cards and their corresponding value, you’ll also become comfortable at things like bulk selling your common cards.
- Choose A Selling Option. If you’re willing to negotiate, you can start selling Yugioh cards on eBay or Reddit to also learn the ropes. In contrast, if you want fast cash, selling Yugioh cards near you at a pawn shop or simply selling cards to an online card buyer are your best options.
Of course, this is mostly a guide for selling individual cards.
If you’re selling Yugioh booster packs or card tins (which is where a lot of the money is), you want to spend more time comparing prices.
Some booster pack and card tins can sell for thousands or tens of thousands of dollars depending on the set, so do your due diligence and compare several selling options before making a decision.
I also suggest checking out House of Champs on YouTube for most tips on how to sell Yugioh cards for cash:
His channel is seriously awesome and covers card prices, selling tips, and guides for making the most out of your card collections.
Extra Reading – Is OfferUp Legit & Worth Selling On?
Selling your Yugioh cards can be a lengthy process, but there is definitely money to be made if you’re willing to do it.
As a side-hustle or way to make money online, it’s a good option if you’re passionate about it.
Buying and selling TCG is a whole job in itself, but if you’re up for the challenge you can get ready to hunt down undervalued cards and sell them for what they’re worth.
Hopefully, this list of the best places to sell Yugioh cards helps you make the most out of your card collection if you don’t want to hold onto them or get back into the game.
Selena Fulham knows how valuable having a side hustle can be. She’s a freelance content writer with a focus on SaaS, B2B technology, social media, and the art of making money online. Currently based in Montreal, Quebec, Selena can usually be found either drinking coffee, hiking up a mountain, or snowboarding down it.