The Best Places To Sell Pokemon Cards For Cash – How To Sell Pokemon Cards!

Chances are, if you grew up in the late 90s/early 2000s or had a kid around the time, you’ve owned Pokemon cards at one time or another.

With over 800 different Pokemon species and millions of fans around the world, there’s no doubt that Pokemon is one of the defining shows and card games of multiple generations.

Plus, with thousands of cards and a variety of different sets and expansions, the world of Pokemon trading cards has a pretty insane amount of depth to it…and a ton of monetary value.

Some Pokemon cards are worth nothing, some are rare, and some are extremely valuable.

In fact, if you can get your hands on cards like a first edition, perfectly rated Charizard, you might be looking at over $300,000 in value with just that single card!

The point is, the world of trading Pokemon cards is insanely valuable, and many collectors view Pokemon cards as both a piece of history and lucrative investment opportunity.

So, if you have any cards saved up from when you were younger or if you still collect, you could potentially be sitting on hundreds or even thousands of dollars.

Of course, there’s a lot you should know in order to avoid undervaluing your Pokemon cards.

Where do you sell them? How do you price them? And what else can I take advantage of?

Stick around until the end to find the answers to all those questions including the best place to sell Pokemon cards!

What Influences Pokemon Card Prices?

Before we get into the best places to sell Pokemon cards, we have to go over how Pokemon cards are valued and what makes expensive cards have such ridiculous price tags.

Generally, Pokemon cards are influenced by a few different factors:

1. Condition.
2. Rarity.
3. Edition.
4. Overall Demand.

Each of these 4 factors can have a dramatic effect on the pricing of the cards, with condition being the overarching factor that can obviously destroy your chances of ever selling a card.

Condition is determined by a few things such as scratches, creases, wear, tear, and liquid damage. You can view a more detailed guide here.

Rarity is determined by the symbols and numbers displayed on the bottom right corner of the card or the bottom right corner of the picture (depending on version of card).

Circles or diamonds aren’t worth much, while stars and first edition symbols can be very rare. 

Edition is determined by special types of cards that were made as part of a unique set. First edition cards are amongst the rarest Pokemon cards in the world.

Overall demand is pretty self-explanatory. If there is an abundance of a specific card, then it obviously won’t be worth much. This somewhat ties in with the rarity of the card.

Ultimately, the goal is to find Pokemon cards that are first edition, rare, and have the highest grade possible: PSA 10 Mint, which basically means it’s a card that went straight from pack opening into a protective sleeve and has never been handled.

The Best Places to Sell Pokemon Cards (Online)

There are a few different places to check out in order to sell your pokemon cards online.

I highly recommend you begin your process of finding places to sell Pokemon cards by looking through your collection first to look for possible first edition or old cards that might be more valuable.

Next, separate out cards that are incredibly worn since these are unlikely to sell.

Once you have a pile of cards you think have some value, you’re ready to find a place to sell your Pokemon cards!

1. Ebay

If you want to have the most control over selling your Pokemon cards, it’s hard to match eBay for online options.

eBay is a clear choice for anyone who wants to sell multiple Pokemon cards at once or even list some of their rarest collections.

There is a huge marketplace on Ebay that people utilize to auction cards in order to get the most value from them.

Ebay won’t really help you figure out the price of your card and it’s worth, so use a site like Pokemon Prices to help you determine the pricing.

All you have to do is enter the card or set name and Pokemon Prices will spit out an estimated price for your card.

Pokemon Prices is an excellent resource no matter which site you decide to sell on and it can help you keep track of your cards and their value while you organize your collection!

Plus, you can even track the historical prices of cards and view pricing trends to see if a card is trending upwards or downwards in value:

If you find some of your cards have value, you can then list them individually on eBay or as a collection for potential buyers.

Just be sure to take quality pictures of the cards from all angles and even close-ups to see any blemishes and marks that may be on the card. 

2. Troll and Toad

Troll and Toad is a massive card marketplace that sells individual cards, rare packs, and even training boxes.

While Pokemon is their largest sector, they also sell other cards from Yugioh to Dragon Ball.

The best part about selling Pokemon cards online with Troll and Toad is that they accept both bulk selling and individual cards.

However, to sell cards on Troll and Toad, you need to have a card worth a minimum of $30 as a personal seller. Additionally, if you’re selling more than $5,000 worth of cards, you need to contact them.

Troll and Toad is somewhat strict, and you should consult the seller’s guide if you want to sell to them to learn the ropes.

However, if you want a reliable place to sell Pokemon cards or to take advantage of their 35% store credit bonus that you can take as payment instead of cash, Troll and Toad is worth considering.

Your card will be found much easier compared to eBay and your card value could be worth more too!

3. Card Market

Card Market is a European online card marketplace that makes selling Pokemon cards extremely easy.

After creating an account, all you have to do is click on sell cards and you will be prompted with a fillable list that helps you with autogenerated search.

Meaning, when you type in the word “Pikachu”, you will get a drop down list of all the different versions of a Pikachu card. From there you can select the proper match and continue filling out your listing as normal!

You set your own price, but you will also be given averages for similar cards that have already been sold on Card Market.

You have to grade your cards using Card Market’s grading guidelines, but this is common for selling Pokemon cards online, so get used to judging your own cards!

4. TCG Player

TCG Player is a massive marketplace for collectible gaming, including games like Magic the Gathering, Yugioh, Cardfight, and Pokemon cards.

Like other vendors, you can also sell your Pokemon cards to TCG Player if you want to get them off your hand for some extra cash.

The set up process is no risk because you don’t have to pay any fees to list items.

Plus, your account includes assistance with thousands of images, descriptions, and rarity levels to help you market your Pokemon cards extremely easy.

TCG Player even has a card scanner with their pro level subscription which literally scans your cards and knows exactly which card it is (including price estimates)!

You have to basically be a business or have a massive collection to qualify for a pro-level subscription, so keep this in mind.

However, even individual sellers can benefit from features like:

• Live pricing data for cards.
• Instantly list thousands of cards with pre-created info.
• Level up your seller account as you sell and get more positive feedback (which makes future selling easier).

Consider using TGC if you have an excessive amount of Pokemon cards because their software is going to be the best for uploading a lot of cards quickly.

Extra Reading – The Best Place To Sell Yugioh Cards.

5. Card Cavern

Card Cavern is an online Pokemon code marketplace that specializes in PTCGO codes, which are online codes for”Pokemon the trading card game online.”

Basically, there are Pokemon cards that have a code on them and if you haven’t redeemed those cards online, you can still sell them on a place like Card Cavern.

The process is digital, assuming you are only selling the code on there and that you’re agreeing to send it over email.

This is a bit different than selling physical cards, of course, but the idea is the same: you can profit by selling Pokemon codes you don’t plan on using.

Card Cavern also has a very user-friendly system where you can sell individual cards on top of code cards and other special edition Pokemon packs.

While this is a more niche way to sell Pokemon cards for cash, it’s certainly one of the best options if you have PTCGO codes to sell.

6. CCG Castle

CCG Castle is another option for selling Pokemon cards online for PayPal cash or store credit.

The process is pretty straightforward. CCG Castle lets you turn on “buy mode” which highlights cards the company is currently buying.

So, you can enable buy mode, browse the website, and make note of the Pokemon cards that are eligible for sale.

You can sell individual cards or Pokemon card collections. CCG Castle doesn’t cover shipping costs, which is a downside worth noting.

But, if you want PayPal cash or some store credit to buy other cards, CCG Castle is another viable option to try.

7. Sell2BBNovelties

Like the name suggests, Sell2BBNovelties is another option to sell collectibles and trading cards like Pokemon for extra cash.

Currently, you have two options for selling Pokemon cards to Sell2BBNovelties:

1. Sell individual cards after referencing the card price using the current buylist or searching the card manually on the website
2. Sell pokemon collections in bulk

Your cards must be in mint or like new condition to be eligible for sale, so no creases, scratches, bends, marks, or white edges.

Additionally, all cards must be the regular U.S. version.

What I like about Sell2BBNovelities is that it lists its bulk buy-back prices. These prices include:

• Holographics: $0.25 each
• Reverse Holographics: $0.06 each
• Rares: $0.05 each
• Commons & Uncommons: $0.02 each
• Energy Cards: $0.005 each

If you have a lot of cards to sell, do some rough math with these bulk prices to find out how much you can earn.

Sell2BBNovelties also offers free shipping if you sell $30 or more, so again, another incentive for bulk card sellers.

8. Dave & Adam’s

Dave & Adam’s is another popular and long-standing trading card seller that’s been in business for over 30 years!

And, while sports cards like baseball cards are a focus of the site, Dave & Adams is still one of the best sites to sell Pokemon cards.

To sell Pokemon cards, you have to visit www.dacardworld.com and look at the current buy list to see what Pokemon cards are eligible for sale.

Dave & Adams usually buys holographic cards, including rare ones like Charizard and Pikachu.

You can also sell booster packs and and booster boxes, and out of all the websites to sell Pokemon cards, I think Dave & Adams commands some of the highest prices next to eBay.

Dave & Adams pays sellers through cash, PayPal, or check. In some cities, a team member can also pick up cards from you.

You usually get paid within 48 hours of Dave & Adams receiving your cards, and overall, this is one of the longer-standing players in the business and reliable way to sell Pokemon cards.

Just note: shipping is only free on sales of $199 or more, so this is best for more serious card sellers.

Additionally, Dave & Adam’s gives out a $25 gift card if you sell over $500 and provide UPS tracking information, so this is another plus for larger sales.

9. Cape Fear Games

If you’re still wondering where to sell Pokemon cards, another option you can try is Cape Fear Games.

This card game shop is perfect for sellers because you can sell cards in bulk as well as individual rare Pokemon cards or even signed cards.

Plus, Cape Fear Games’ buy list provides information on what type of cards the company wants to buy and a rough estimate of how much cards are worth.

You start the selling process by using a buylist search tool to see if Cape Fear Games wants your cards.

From there, you choose a payment method. Cape Fear Games can pay you with:

• PayPal
• Check
• Store credit
• MTGOTraders credit

Once you choose a payment method, you submit your buylist request which contains info on the Pokemon cards you’re selling and card condition.

If Cape Fear Games wants to buy your cards, the company emails you a confirmation email.

You have to package and ship your cards to Cape Fear Games. But if you’re selling cards in bulk and want a simple selling process, Cape Fear Games is another great option for selling Pokemon cards online.

Where to Sell Pokemon Cards Near Me?

If you have a card collection but don’t want to go through the hassle of selling your cards online, you still have options!

In fact, even in my own city, there’s plenty of places that buy Pokemon cards near me that would be an easy way to turn my cards into cash.

Just remember, make sure you check the price of your valuable cards before you try and sell to ensure you don’t get ripped off!

Anway, here are a few common places that buy Pokemon cards in your area.

1. Pawn Shops

If you have a pawn shop near you, chances are that they’ll take Pokemon cards there or at least consider the idea, especially if you have some rare cards and the owner knows anything about Pokemon.

The process is fairly simple as long as you’re confident in your pricing and know how to properly negotiate to get your cards true worth.

Doing a quick Google search for “Pokemon cards pawn shops” will most likely yield a decent amount of shops nearby that accept/offer card selling and trading.

If I were you, I wouldn’t check out any pawn shops that don’t mention card selling. They usually don’t buy cards because they don’t know anything about them.

At the very least, call some shops in your area to double check they buy Pokemon cards and then head to them with your binder of cards to start negotiating!

Extra Reading – The Best Things To Pawn.

2. Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist

Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist are other options to find people buying Pokemon cards in your area.

Not only will the buyer be able to see the card in-person to help you sell quicker, but you can probably find buyers who are interested in collections and box sets, so bulk selling is fast.

Another great thing about these marketplaces is that you can set a specific radius from your house so you don’t have to go out of your way to sell at a far distance.

Keep in mind that pricing isn’t easy when you sell through Facebook or Craigslist, so you have to do some research to know the value of your collection.

Extra Reading – The Best Things To Sell On Facebook Marketplace.

3. Comic Book Stores

If there’s one reliable bet for places that buy Pokemon cards near you, it’s comic book stores.

Comic book stores almost always sell their own cards, so buying cards from local players helps them expand their inventory.

Now, the only downside to this method is that comic book stores need to make a profit too, so they’re probably going to low-ball you.

However, the advantage is that you can probably offload your cards quickly and you know the store is likely interested.

I highly recommend going to a few stores and getting an offer from each one before making a decision on who to sell to. You might be able to maximize your profits.

What Option Is Best?

If you’re not sure about whether or not you should sell Pokemon cards online or in-person, hopefully this explanation will help you understand the difference…

If you have very valuable cards that are worth a lot, you may want to consider selling online through a trusted site listed above.

Additionally, selling online will be a longer process as orders don’t come in immediately. However, you will have a much higher chance of getting your card sold at full price.

If you are selling in bulk and have full packs that you can organize together, in-person selling might be a better option for you.

Sometimes people just want to get rid of their entire collection altogether and selling in-person is a really easy way to do so.

Organize your cards in value, rarity, packs, editions, etc and see which ones fit the proper selling type.

Chances are, you’ll have to sell online and in-person if you have a large enough collection.

Tips For How To Sell Pokemon Cards

It doesn’t matter if you’re wondering how to sell Pokemon cards online or want to sell Pokemon cards near you; there are several selling tips to help make your life easier.

A lot of this has to do with simplifying organization, which helps you sell faster and also ensure you get fair prices for your cards.

Some tips for how to sell Pokemon cards more effectively include:

1. Trim The Collection: Start by separating cards that clearly have a lot of damage and wear out of your collection since it’s highly unlikely you can sell these cards anywhere.
2. Sort Cards By Set: Any website or local pawn shop that wants to buy Pokemon cards from you needs to know what set your cards are in. This is because some sets, like first edition cards, are the most valuable since they are the oldest cards in circulation and aren’t being printed anymore.
3. Sort Cards By Rarity: Once you group cards by set/edition, sort them into different piles based on rarity. This means organizing cards into holographic, reverse holographic, rare, uncommon, and common piles.
4. Sort Cards By Condition: It’s important to grade your Pokemon cards before selling them so you have a general idea of their PSA grade. A card’s grade has a massive influence on price; the difference between a PSA 8 and PSA 10 for example can be thousands or tens of thousands of dollars for very rare cards. You can use a PSA guide to grade cards yourself. If you’re a serious seller or have a lot of first-edition, rare cards in good condition, you can consider finding a professional PSA grader to appraise your cards. While this might cost some money and time, if your cards are worth thousands of dollars, it’s critical to get a legit PSA grade so you can make the most money.
5. Record Your Prices: Once you have a PSA grade for the cards you want to sell, double-check card prices with websites like Pokemon Price. You should record each card and the corresponding price in a spreadsheet that you’ll use when selling online or in-store.
6. Make The Sale: Once you know all of your card’s approximate grades and prices, you’re ready to sell online or in-store! Having your pricing database is especially helpful if you sell in-person so you don’t get ripped off and can reference how much a card should generally be worth before you sell.

That’s a nutshell guide on how to sell Pokemon cards for cash.

You can also checkout this YouTube video from TwicebakedJake for more Pokemon card selling tips to learn the ropes before making your first sale:

Just remember to always read buy lists and selling rules so you know the types of cards stores are buying and what conditions your cards should be in.

It’s possible to make an incredible amount of money with this side hustle idea, but it also takes time to properly sort, grade, and find the right buyer for your cards.

Hopefully, our list of the best places to sell Pokemon cards help you make some extra cash with your old collection of cards!

Final Word

Pokemon cards brought us a ton of joy when we were younger and even now. they can create some fun once again with the aspect of trading and selling.

Selling your collection now could potentially make you hundreds or even thousands of dollars if you know what you’re doing and where to sell.

However, the best place to sell Pokemon cards is not a set in stone thing.

Every seller will maximize their profits by selling through different marketplaces.

Make the most out of it by doing your research on each card (especially if it’s a valuable one) and eventually you’ll get the hang of price estimates.

Who knows… you might end up having a ton of fun diving back into the nostalgia of it all and start selling Pokemon cards as a fun side hustle!

Looking for other selling side hustles? Checkout:

• Where To Sell Beanie Babies For Cash.
• The Best Places To Sell Old Board Games.
• Where To Sell Old Postcards For Cash.